I feel like I am torturing you guys with my tear-jerker dog stories.  But, every story has an ending.  I feel I owe it to you – and Ellie – to share the end of her story.

After a few days of watching Ellie decline, Phil and I decided it was time to end our dog’s life.  We called the vet and made “the appointment” for the Friday after Christmas.  Phil and I took turns being the one that freaks out and the one who says, “We just need to have faith that we are doing the right thing.”

But what does even mean?

Anne Lamott says that the opposite of faith is not doubt, but certainty.  I find this comforting, because the older I get, the less certain I am about anything.

On that Friday morning, I stood in the shower until the water ran cold.  I prayed, Please tell me this is the right thing.  Please tell me this is the right thing. This is the right thing….right? Can you send me a sign?

I have a deep but amnestic faith in God.  My signature prayer, the one I say every morning, is one of the ADD variety:  Good morning G-Money.  Please help me find you today, and then please remind me to look, or that I even asked you in the first place.  Amen. 

We declared Friday a “lump day,” a day spent lying on the couch like a lump.  Ellie, who in 9 years was never allowed on the furniture, got the best spot.


Phil and I picked Ellie out together, and we needed to say goodbye to her together.  Me, Phil, and our friend Jameson.


The walk into the animal hospital was surreal, Ellie still half-heartedly sniffing the grass as she stopped for a final pit stop.  Despite the vet’s reassurances, my silent prayer for help played on a continuous loop in my mind: Please tell me this is the right thing.  Give me a sign that we are doing the right thing.  

And then something weird happened.

Ellie was really Phil’s dog.  He is the master, the alpha-male.  As females, there was always a low level of competition between Ellie and I….a desire for Phil’s attention, I guess. When Phil would travel for work, Ellie would get pissed, and let me know by eating garbage, specifically tampons.  There has to be some symbolism to the tampons, right?


But as we sat down next to her on the floor of the vet’s office, she rested her head in my lap.  Not Phil’s, mine.  She looked up at me with those big, pooly brown eyes and with them said to me, “I need you right now.  Not as a substitute for Phil; you.  I need you here right now, holding my face.  And please don’t look away.  I need you to not look away.”

Maybe it was the whiskey talking, but I was pretty certain that was my sign.

The doctor talked us through the process as she injected the medication.  I held Ellie’s face and she stared into my eyes with a look of pure trust – so intimate that it almost became too much for me, and I was tempted to look away.  But I willed myself to hang in there.  Within what was probably a split-second – but seemed so much longer, as if in slow motion – I went from looking deep into her brown eyes to suddenly seeing my own face reflected in them.  And I knew that was it.  She wasn’t seeing me anymore. She wasn’t there.  As the deluge of tears ran down my face, I tried to picture her soul rising up and running….running like she used to, chasing a skunk like a bat out of hell.

Why did she come to me?  In The Art of Racing in the Rain, the protagonist -a dog named Enzo – says: “There are things that only dogs and women understand because we tap into pain directly from its source.”  Maybe that was why.

Or maybe she chose me because she knew I needed it.  I needed her to forgive me for flipping out about the tampons. I needed her to know that I loved her. I needed her to tell me that she was going to be ok.  And she did.

The next morning, after reading the book Dog Heaven with the girls for the 58th time, we decided to draw our own versions of Dog Heaven.

Image 1 Image 2

When we asked Phoebe to describe her picture, she explained: “Well, that’s me and Ellie surfing, and over there is Nannie and Aunt Terry having cocktails.” Of course.

Emma’s spoke for itself:


Much of the research I found says you should be 100% honest with your kids about death; that any watered down version is to rob them of the death experience.  Maybe.  But my gut feeling was that to describe euthanasia and cremation to my young children would be to rob them of something…of their sense of wonder, of their version of faith and God.  Maybe I will regret that decision one day, but right now I have to have faith that it was the right one for us.

John Lennon said: “I believe in everything until it is disproved.  So I believe in fairies, myths, and dragons.  It all exists, even if it’s in your mind.”

So if my kids want to put their faith in a dog heaven where cocktails are served and doggie treats fall from the sky into the peanut butter river, who am I to say that it doesn’t exist?

Five days later, I am still seeing Ellie out of the corner of my eye.  When I walk on the beach, I think every dog is her.  When I slice an apple, I wait for her to come running for her share.  Then I remember.  And the sadness is crushing.

But then I think about her running through grassy fields to the peanut butter river, and I smile.


27 thoughts on “Faith

  1. Oh, oh. I am reading this with tears rolling down my cheeks. I am so, so sorry for your loss and that final moment just takes my breath away – I am certain you will never forget it, and that it was your sign. I think the way you’ve handled it with your girls is just perfect. And that Anne Lamott line is one of the ones that I most frequently return to. My certainty wanes in direct proportion to my age, too. xox

  2. I’m so in awe of how you handled Emma’s death with the kids. I loved Emma’s description of heaven for a dog. I like to think that a grown-up heaven is filled with dogs because their unconditional love and affection on earth makes it like heaven for us.

  3. Oh Jess – I have a huge lump in my throat and my heart aches for you. Death is a part of life – something I have yet to experience on such an intimate level – but you handled it so gracefully for your girls. I hope the coming days will be better for you — and you absolutely did the right thing by Ellie. xxoo

    • Thanks Em! Yes it was a tough situation in many ways, but we got through it and hopefully the healing has already begun. Thanks or your kind words of support. Will give you a call soon. xo

  4. This is a beautiful tribute. I had a similar experience almost two years ago with our dog. Your words brought it all back and speak perfectly to how I was feeling, down to thinking I saw her out of the corner of my eye in the days after. It was one of the hardest times of my life. I haven’t read the previous posts about your dog, but you clearly loved her, so yes–you did the right thing.

    • Thank you Jessica! It is so hard, there is just no other say to describe it. So much harder than I had anticipated. Ellie was so chilled out and mellow, yet for 9 years she was always there….it’s weird. Thanks for your comments;)

  5. Thank you for so eloquently putting this decision. As a longtime dog-lover, I identified. It brought me to tears & back to when I had to make that painful decision w/many dogs. XO

  6. thank you for sharing so much of yourself. Your (and Phil’s) actions for Ellie’s final day was just what she (and you) needed. I love your girls’ descriptions of heaven. Thank you for sharing your heart with us. xxxooo

  7. You haven’t tortured us…you would only be torturing yourself if you didn’t let it go, express her life and yours, and share it with us. Thanks for sharing with us. I admire your mothering of Emma, Phoebe and Ellie (and Phil:). I aspire to do the same. God bless!

    • Aww, thanks. It does feel good to let her go and start the healing process. The kids (and Phil) have been great support to me as well, so it’s a team effort for sure! miss you girl – hope to see you soon. xo

  8. So sorry about Ellie, Jessie! Loved your post…brought me to tears! Happy New Year! Have fun at the wedding!! Tell the girls and Phil hello…Ryan said to me the other day “mom, you know who I miss” and I said “who”? She said “Emma”….please share with her:) Xo Chrissy

    Sent from my iPhone

  9. Broken hearts are hard to mend especially when it comes to your beloved pet who was/is a member of your family and will always be there is spirit. Emma and Phoebe are so fortunate to have you as their amazing mother. Thank you for your vulnerability, honesty and most of all your love. Please keep writing for you and for us…

    • Carolyn you always bring tears to my eyes with your warm, loving and supportive words. I feel like you see right into my heart. Thank you for this!!!! Hope to see you in person soon xoxo

  10. Amazing, beautiful, sad and heartwarming. There is a poem called The Rainbow Bridge, it’s about where dogs go when they pass away. It’s where they run through meadows, free of pain. The sun always shines and they wait for their owners to pass by when they themselves pass away. I think that Emma’s version of Dog Heaven is even better!
    Love to you all. Ellie is better now, you did right by her.
    ~Liz and Four Boston Terriers~

    • Aww, that you Liz. I will have to find that poem. Yes Emma is a pretty awesome kid. She blows me away with her ability to create and express.
      I feel better knowing you thought we handled things well, being the dog-lover and advocate that you are! When the time is right you will have to help us find our next dog to love. xoxox

  11. Pingback: My Dog Is Dead and We’re Moving: How to Choose an Attitude of Abundance | No Cigarettes, No Bologna

  12. Pingback: Into The Woods | No Cigarettes, No Bologna

  13. When someone writes an piece of writing he/she maintains
    the thought of a user in his/her mind that how a user can be
    aware of it. Therefore that’s why this paragraph is great.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s